5 more new cars to avoid at all costs, and 5 alternatives to consider

For car buyers, 2025 was the year of incentives. If you were in the market for a new vehicle in the first half of last year, consider yourself lucky.

After the 25% tariffs on automotive imports were announced in March, many car shoppers snagged new vehicles before price hikes reached dealer lots.

A February consumer poll from CivicScience found that six in 10 Americans would switch to an alternative brand or stop purchasing an affected product if their favorite brand were affected by tariffs.

Last year, major automakers were paying buyers up to $2,000 to switch brands through so-called “conquest cash incentives” that were often stacked on top of other offers.  

Retail consumers spent $620 billion on new vehicles in 2025, according to Automotive World, citing J.D. Power data, a nearly 6% increase from the previous year. However, the increase was driven by a threat that never really materialized.

“Despite much speculation regarding major increases in new vehicle prices due to tariffs, the actual increases, as correctly predicted by J.D. Power, have been muted,” the firm said.

The average retail transaction price for all vehicles in December was estimated at $47,104, a $715 (1.5%) increase from the same period last year. Without EVs, which are on average more expensive than traditional combustion-engine vehicles, average car prices rose 1.4% to $46,807.

If you are one of those six in 10 Americans looking to change car brands, TheStreet covered Consumer Reports list of popular vehicles to avoid and the ones to consider instead here.

Here are another five vehicles to consider in 2026.

Consumer Reports identifies better alternatives to some of the most popular vehicle options.

Photo by Halfpoint Images on Getty Images

What is Consumer Reports, and how did it compile this list?

Founded in 1936 by a group of workers fired from a product-testing firm called Consumers’ Research, Consumer Reports is a multifaceted nonprofit organization that aims to educate consumers about products and help them make informed purchasing decisions.

It does this by purchasing and testing products directly, administering detailed surveys to its members about the products they own and use, and investigating the veracity of manufacturers’ claims.

Consumer Reports at a glance

  • Founded: 1936 (as Consumers Union by former employees of Consumers’ Research, fired after they attempted to unionize)
  • Headquartered: Yonkers, NY
  • Leadership: Marta Tellado (president and CEO)
  • Employees: Approx. 500 to 600
  • Members: At least 6 million
  • Mission statement: “Consumer Reports is an independent, nonprofit member organization that works side by side with consumers for truth, transparency, and fairness in the marketplace.”

Consumer Reports’ slogan, “Smarter choices for a better world,” captures the organization’s purpose. CR aims to educate and inform the public by providing objective information about popular products, helping consumers make “smarter choices” when purchasing major items.

For this list, Consumer Reports uses the ratings and ranks based on testing and what its members tell them in surveys.

This review focused on the top-selling models (based on sales and registration data) in nine different categories. The alternatives to these popular models are in the same genre but have higher ratings.

Consumer Reports says avoid these popular cars and buy these alternatives instead

The car to avoid will be listed first, while the CR-recommended alternative will appear second.

Popular luxury mid-sized SUV to avoid: 2026 Land Rover Defender

Land Rover

  • Price Range: $63,500 – $168,700
  • CR MPG: Overall 18/ City 12/ Hwy 26 mpg
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #12 of 17

Luxury mid-sized SUV to buy: 2026 BMW X5

BMW

  • Price Range: $67,600 – $129,700
  • CR MPG: Overall 23/ City 15/ Hwy 33
  • Consumer Reports Rankings: #1 of 17

Popular minivan to avoid: 2026 Chrysler Pacifica Hybrid

Chrysler

  • Price Range: $43,945 – $60,465
  • CR MPG: Overall 27/ City 21/ Hwy 32
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #7 of #7 minivans, 3-row

3-row minivan to buy: 2026 Kia Carnival Hybrid

Kia

  • Price Range: $41,390 – $53,490
  • CR MPG: Overall 31/ City 26/ Hwy 34 mpg
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #1 of 7

Popular electric SUV to avoid: 2026 Honda Prologue

Honda

  • Price Range: $47,400 – $57,900
  • CR MPGe: Overall 95/ City 101/ Hwy 88 mpge
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #10 of 22

Electric SUV to buy: 2026 Tesla Model Y

Tesla

  • Price Range: $39,990 – $59,990
  • CR MPGe: Overall 123/ City 130/ Hwy 115 mpge
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #1 of 22 electric SUVs

Popular small car to avoid: 2026 Volkswagen Jetta

Volkswagen

  • Price Range: $23,995 – $29,995
  • CR MPG: Overall 34/ City 21/ Hwy 54 mpg
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #21 of 22

Small car to buy: 2026 Honda Civic

Honda

  • Price Range: $29,395 – $33,595
  • CR MPG: Overall 44/ City 39/ Hwy 48
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #1 or 22

Popular mid-sized car to avoid: 2026 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid

Hyundai

  • Price Range: $29,200 – $38,250
  • CR MPG: Overall 44/ City 36/ Hwy 51
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #9 of 10 mid-sized cars

Mid-sized cars to buy: 2026 Toyota Camry

Toyota

  • Price Range: $29,100 – $37,025
  • CR MPG: Overall 48/ City 40/ Hwy 54
  • Consumer Reports Ranking: #1 of 10 mid-sized cars

Related: US car buyers reverse major trend in second half of 2025