New Congress has tough decision to make on Social Security

Social Security’s money troubles just landed on a new Congress. With the program’s trust funds heading toward depletion, the lawmakers elected in the midterms may change the taxes Americans pay, from the cap on payroll taxes to a $6,000 senior deduction that is set to expire in two years.

The stakes are huge. Democrats won control of both chambers, and they now inherit a program that nearly 71 million Americans depend on.

Under current law, the average retired worker’s monthly check would get an automatic 22% cut once reserves run dry. Social Security’s funding clock keeps ticking.

Social Security’s funding clock keeps ticking

The retirement trust fund may run out in 2032, when only 78% of scheduled benefits would be payable. If it is combined with the disability fund, the depletion date moves to 2034, when 83% of benefits could be paid, according to the Social Security Administration.

Also read: Social Security announces new cost-of-living adjustment for 2027

The outlook worsened this year. The 2026 Trustees Report moved the retirement fund’s depletion to the fourth quarter of 2032, about a quarter earlier than before. A newly retired dual-income couple could lose about $16,900 a year depending on their combined payments.

“The last comprehensive effort to improve Social Security’s solvency took place over 40 years ago,” said Sen. Mike Crapo (R-Idaho), as reported by TheStreet.

The long-range gap is also growing. Over 75 years, the shortfall rose to $29.3 trillion from $25.1 trillion. “We need to either raise scheduled revenue, reduce scheduled benefits or some combination of the two,” said Social Security Chief Actuary Karen Glenn.

Part of the problem is how the program is funded. Payroll taxes supplied 91% of Social Security’s revenue in 2025, but the share of GDP subject to that tax fell from 41% in 1984 to 34%.

AARP research found that most analysts blame demographic pressures, but its own analysis points to income changes as the main driver eroding the program’s revenue base.

Why the payroll tax cap is back on the table

Workers and employers each pay 6.2% on earnings up to $184,500 this year, a limit that rises to $192,300 in 2027. Sen. Bernie Sanders called scrapping the cap a “top priority,” while Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy criticized the idea of putting a 12.4% tax on people who are not millionaires or billionaires, according to CNBC.

The idea has drawn support from both parties. Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-Ohio) have called lifting the cap a “common-sense solution,” and the Alliance for Retired Americans says eight Democratic Senate candidates backed eliminating or raising it, as reported by Newsweek.

Lifting the cap would not fix everything. A Social Security Administration analysis found that eliminating the cap starting in 2027 would close 58% of the 75-year funding gap, while applying the tax to earnings above $250,000 would close 57%. A University of Maryland survey also found 79% of adults support higher taxes on wages over $400,000.

Sanders wants to use the extra money to expand benefits by $2,400 a year, applying the 6.2% tax to income above $250,000, including investment income. Not everyone is convinced.

“Scrapping the payroll tax cap would certainly help address some of Social Security’s funding issues,” said Kevin Thompson of 9i Capital Group, though he questioned whether expanding benefits is necessary while solvency problems remain, Newsweek reported.

Sanders is expected to chair the Senate Finance subcommittee on Social Security starting in January 2027.

Kevin Carter / Getty Images

The $6,000 senior deduction is on a clock, too

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, signed in July 2025, created a deduction of up to $6,000 for each eligible person aged 65 and older, or $12,000 for married couples, for tax years 2025 through 2028.

It phases out above $75,000 of income for single filers and $150,000 for couples, and it is a deduction, not an end to taxes on benefits, CNBC reported.

The benefit is smaller than the headlines suggest. The White House estimates about 33.9 million seniors will gain around $670 each on average, while the Peterson Foundation found fewer than half of older adults will see a meaningful benefit.

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget also estimates the deduction and related cuts will reduce revenue flowing to Social Security by about $30 billion a year, as reported by TheStreet.

More Social Security:

That revenue hit has not gone unnoticed. Under the law, 88% of beneficiaries would effectively pay no federal tax on their Social Security income.

The trustees said the deduction had a “substantial effect” on the trust fund’s finances, and congressional Democrats unanimously opposed the law that created it.

Still, the break may outlive its end date. Because 2028 is a presidential election year, neither party is likely to let the senior tax cuts expire.

What the new Congress can realistically do

Sanders is expected to chair the Senate Finance subcommittee on Social Security starting in January 2027. Even so, President Donald Trump has said he would veto legislation he opposes, and most bills still need 60 votes in the Senate. Sanders’ own bill remains stuck in the Senate Finance Committee.

Other plans face the same wall. The Social Security 2100 Act from Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.) and Rep. John Larson (D-Conn.) would raise payroll taxes on high earners and change how cost-of-living adjustments are calculated, but analysts give the bill little chance of advancing in the current political environment.

That means action may wait. Raising the cap to $300,000 would cost a worker at that level about $6,700 more a year. The Tax Foundation’s William McBride warned of an “unprecedented increase” in marginal tax rates, while Dan Adcock of the National Committee to Preserve Social Security and Medicare called growing Republican openness “a crack in the dam.”

Related: AARP cuts to the chase on 2027 Social Security COLA