Retired Americans face alarming six-figure threat to Social Security benefits

Nearly 70 million Americans receive Social Security benefits, and the majority of senior recipients rely on monthly payments to supplement their retirement income.

Although the Social Security Administration has faced potential insolvency for decades, declining birth rates, combined with longer life expectancies, have created financial pressure on the federal program.

While some experts have suggested removing the cap on Social Security taxes for high earners to address the funding gap, widespread reform is unlikely to pass in the near future.

🏦 🏡 Don’t miss the move: SIGN UP for TheStreet’s FREE daily newsletter 🏦 🏡

The Social Security Board of Trustees released its annual report earlier this month, reiterating last year’s findings that the program is on track to become insolvent within the next decade, forcing a reduction in benefits for seniors.

However, the actual financial impact on retired households may be far greater than expected. To make up for lower Social Security checks in the future, seniors will need to contribute more to their retirement plans to offset the loss.

Social Security is crucial to supplementing retirement income for seniors, and many experts note that the program is at risk.

Image source: Shutterstock

Social Security funding gaps will reduce benefits for retired Americans by over $100,000

The 2025 Social Security Board of Trustees report was released earlier this month, reiterating last year’s findings that retirement benefits are on track to become insolvent by 2033, with all Social Security Trust funds depleted by 2035. After that, seniors will see a 23% reduction in their Social Security payments.

This shortfall would cut seniors’ payments by $4,039 per year, amounting to $100,980 over the course of the average length of retirement. However, the median retirement account balance is $87,000, meaning that most Americans will be even further behind in their savings plans.

As the cost of living continues to rise, impacting essentials like food, housing, and health care, workers will need to increase their 401(k) and IRA contributions to supplement their savings. 

More on retirement & social security:

“Social Security is the backbone of retirement income for most Americans,” said PensionBee CEO Romi Savova. “These figures highlight a stark reality: retirement is a personal responsibility, and the safety net is getting thinner.”

However, younger workers may have a slight advantage over those approaching retirement now. Having more time to save and build interest on a retirement portfolio provides more opportunity to offset the loss from lower Social Security checks.

Younger generations have more time to plan for losses to Social Security

Although it’s long been possible that Social Security could exhaust its funds, the threat of insolvency is now stronger than ever. 

Despite the fact that most Americans under 45 aren’t confident Social Security will be around at all when they retire, younger workers have more time to plan for the reality of reduced benefits.

Related: Your Social Security income may change because of a new rule

A 25-year-old worker would only need to save an additional $35 per month, or $708 per year over 42 years, to recoup the $100,000 lost in reduced Social Security payments. However, a 45-year-old worker would need to increase their annual contributions by over $2,000, and a 55-year-old would need to save an additional $6,000 per year.

“The longer you have to prepare, the more manageable the impact of potential cuts — and the less you need to contribute in total,” Savova continued.

Although the fate of Social Security is tenuous, early preparation and consistent saving can help offset benefit reductions in the future.

Related: Veteran fund manager unveils eye-popping S&P 500 forecast