Richard, a Boston caller with $80,426 in debt and virtually no income, recently sought advice from Dave Ramsey, CEO of Ramsey Solutions and host of “The Ramsey Show,” on how to escape his mounting obligations.
His debt included roughly $68,000 in credit card balances accumulated during an undiagnosed manic episode and a $12,000 car loan.
Ramsey advised him to avoid bankruptcy and stop paying his credit card bills, allowing them to default.
While the strategy could ease Richard’s immediate financial pressure, it carries a potential consequence that could make his situation even more difficult: The IRS may treat forgiven credit card debt as taxable income, leaving him with an unexpected tax bill.
Also Read: Dave Ramsey’s blunt truth on the only real hack for paying off debt
Ramsey’s playbook for Richard’s $80,426 crisis
Dave Ramsey told Richard to pay only the car loan minimum, attack the smallest credit card balance first using the debt snowball method, and stop paying the remaining cards altogether.
Ramsey argued on the show that when a borrower has no income and cannot cover minimum payments across multiple cards, partial payments only delay default while draining cash needed for essentials.
Ramsey told Richard to keep paying the car loan because the vehicle is essential for finding work, and losing it to repossession would set back his ability to regain income.
His resistance to bankruptcy reflects personal experience. Ramsey filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy in 1988 after over-leveraging real estate investments, and he has said that this experience shaped his financial philosophy.
Credit card charge-offs and what they mean for borrowers like Richard
When a borrower stops paying on credit cards for roughly 180 days, the issuer typically charges off the account, writes off the balance as a loss, and sells the debt to a third-party collector, according to the Federal Reserve’s Asset Classification.
That process destroys the borrower’s credit score and opens the door to collection calls, lawsuits, and wage garnishment.
More Dave Ramsey:
- Dave Ramsey warns American workers on 401(k)s, IRAs, Social Security
- Dave Ramsey warns Americans on 401(k) plans
- Dave Ramsey says this insurance product is horrendous for families
The credit card charge-off rate across all commercial banks reached 3.82% in the second quarter of 2026, down from the Q3 2024 peak of 4.69%, according to Federal Reserve data.
Delinquency rates on credit card loans declined to 2.85% in Q2 2026, down from 3.04% a year earlier, Federal Reserve Board data showed.
Fewer cardholders are falling behind, but the elevated charge-off rate signals that borrowers who missed payments months ago are now reaching the stage where banks permanently write off their balances.
Credit card charge-offs remain elevated, signaling the lasting consequences of missed payments as borrowers face damaged credit scores, collections, and potential lawsuits.
The hidden tax bill that follows forgiven credit card debt
When a creditor cancels $600 or more of debt, the IRS requires that creditor to file a Form 1099-C, Cancellation of Debt, and send a copy to the borrower.
The canceled amount generally counts as ordinary taxable income, the IRS Taxpayer Advocate Service confirmed, which means Richard’s $68,000 in forgiven credit card debt could push him into the 22% federal tax bracket and generate a federal tax bill of roughly $7,000 before any exclusions, according to IRS Revenue Procedure 2025-32.
That tax exposure comes as U.S. households carry $1.26 trillion in credit card debt, according to the New York Fed’s Q2 2026 Household Debt and Credit Report.
Bruce McClary, senior vice president of communications at the National Foundation for Credit Counseling (NFCC), has described the pressure facing these borrowers in stark terms.
<strong>Debt is no longer a background concern, but a daily struggle for many families. People are having to make some really tough decisions</strong>.
McClary has also cautioned borrowers against firms that advise them to stop making payments immediately. “That is like dropping a nuclear bomb on your credit report,” he warned in a report published by AARP.
One safeguard in the tax code could reduce the hit. The IRS offers an insolvency exclusion, which lets borrowers exclude canceled debt from taxable income when the debt is forgiven.
Borrowers must file IRS Form 982 with their return to claim it, and the exclusion is capped at the exact amount of insolvency.
Steps credit counselors recommend before letting credit cards default
Guidance from AARP frames letting credit cards default as a last-resort move, warning that firms urging borrowers to stop paying creditors can trigger lawsuits and credit damage that outlast the original balances by years.
Experian recommends contacting each credit card issuer to ask about hardship programs before missing a single payment. Many issuers offer temporary reduced interest rates, waived fees, or modified payment schedules for unemployed borrowers, and these programs do not appear on a credit report the same way a charge-off does.
McClary told CNBC that borrowers facing this kind of pressure should contact a nonprofit credit counselor accredited by the National Foundation for Credit Counseling before deciding to stop making payments.
A nonprofit counselor can negotiate reduced interest rates across multiple accounts and build a debt management plan that keeps accounts current. “Reach out and talk to someone before making any big decisions on your own,” he recommended.
A counselor can also review the borrower’s state statute of limitations on credit card debt, which governs how long a creditor can legally sue to recover an unpaid balance and varies from three to 10 years depending on the state, Bankrate reported.
Related: Dave Ramsey limits family lending to one of two options
